👷
Plain-English guide

Workplace injuries: comp vs. lawsuit

Work injuries run on different rails than other injury claims. Workers' compensation pays medical costs and part of your wages no matter whose fault the injury was — but in exchange, you generally can't sue your employer, and comp never pays for pain and suffering.

What workers' comp actually pays

Medical treatment for the injury, temporary disability checks (typically about two-thirds of your average weekly wage, up to a state maximum), and a permanent disability award if you don't fully recover — calculated from your impairment rating and your state's schedule of benefits. Every state's schedule and maximum is different, which is why 'workers comp settlement chart' searches are always state-specific — our state comp pages carry each state's verified numbers.

The third-party claim most people miss

If anyone other than your employer contributed to your injury — a negligent driver, a defective machine's manufacturer, a subcontractor on your site — you may have a regular injury lawsuit against them alongside the comp claim. Third-party claims pay full damages including pain and suffering, which comp never does. This is the single most commonly missed source of recovery in work injury cases.

The impairment rating is the whole comp fight

Once you reach maximum medical improvement, a doctor assigns an impairment rating — and that percentage multiplies straight through the award formula, which makes it the most-contested number in the system. Insurer-selected doctors rate conservatively; nearly every state gives you a path to challenge with an independent medical examination. A three-point rating difference on a scheduled member routinely changes the award by thousands.

Settling a comp claim

Comp settlements trade your future benefits for a lump sum. Before accepting one, know your impairment rating, your state's formula, whether the settlement closes your future medical rights — and, if you're on or near Medicare, whether a set-aside is required. A comp attorney's fee is capped by statute in most states, typically 10–25%, which makes advice comparatively cheap in exactly the system where the formulas are hardest to read.

RememberThis guide is educational information, not legal advice. SettlementRange is not a law firm. State rules vary — talk to a licensed attorney in your state before acting on any claim.
Common questions

FAQ

How is a workers' comp settlement calculated?

The core formula in most states: your weekly comp rate (about two-thirds of your average wage, capped at a state maximum) × the scheduled weeks for your body part × your impairment rating. A 10% arm rating at a $600 comp rate against a 312-week schedule is $600 × 31.2 = $18,720. Our comp calculator runs it with your state's numbers where we've verified them.

Can I sue my employer for a work injury?

Generally no — comp is the exclusive remedy against employers, with narrow exceptions (intentional harm, no comp insurance). But anyone else who contributed is fair game in a third-party claim: equipment makers, drivers, other contractors. That claim pays the pain and suffering comp doesn't.

Should I accept the insurance company's comp settlement offer?

Not before three checks: does the number match your state's formula for your rating and wage (run it), does the settlement close future medical care (a fair-looking number can be terrible if it does), and does Medicare need a set-aside? Comp offers are opening positions like any other.

Put numbers on it — with the math shown.

Run the scheduled-award formula for your injury